Search Results
Search this site
116 results found with an empty search
- Antisemitism Isn’t Hiding—It’s Evolving on UC Campuses
As this school year comes to a close, it’s clear that antisemitic incidents across University of California campuses are not following suit, but escalating. From protests against former hostages, to promoting suicide bombers, and targeting Jewish students online, antisemitism is alive and well, as it has been for years. Regardless of the different faces antisemitism wears, these are not isolated incidents. They point to a larger, more uncomfortable truth that antisemitism is not a relic of the past, but rather it’s adapting to the present. Actions that are often framed as “anti-Zionism” on college campuses across America are increasingly showing up as a socially acceptable mask for antisemitism. These incidents are seeping into Jewish spaces and targeting Jewish students and identities in ways that are becoming concerningly normalized and dismissible. Just last month, Omar Shem Tov, an Israeli hostage who survived 505 days of torture in Gaza, came to speak at UCLA and was greeted with a host of antisemetic protesters. He faced the hostility of crowds, treated as if he himself were a terrorist, not a victim of them. The UCLA Undergraduate Student Association council claimed that hosting a survivor of Hamas captivity was “obscuring the broader reality of ongoing state violence.” As if to say that offering students a chance to develop some empathy toward the suffering of Israelis caught in the middle of the war is somehow an attempt to spread prejudice against Palestinians. Ironically, their stance suggests that the exact opposite has already taken root. Despite this reaction, Omar still pulled in his message that even after experiencing the unimaginable, his message promotes empathy and humanity. You can’t fight darkness with darkness, you have to bring in the light”. Although the negative reaction to UCLA was widely publicized, other campuses greeted him with compassion and understanding. In stark contrast with UCLA students’ problematic reaction, UC Berkeley thought it would be appropriate to host a failed Palestinian suicide bomber to deliver a speech to students for a “Palestinian Political Prisoners Day” event during the same week. It’s worth noting that she wasn’t some freedom fighter targeting a military site; the woman was arrested after attempting to ignite a car bomb near a civilian neighborhood and was heard shouting the Islamic Supremacist call to violence against infidels, “Allahu Akbar.” The mass murder attempt severely disfigured herself and the Israeli police officer who confronted her. This clearly crosses from political discourse into moral distortion, and it raises questions like: Why is violence against Israelis, and by extension Jews, being normalized? Why are we praising martyrs? And how have we come to live in a world where suicide bombers are praised, and former hostages are shamed? Meanwhile, throughout April, at UCSB, Hillel was busy promoting their most exciting event of the year, a Jewish prom. Despite promoting an event that was only meant to bring joy and fun to the community, Hillel was met with a host of online antisemitism. Comments like “Will there be a bomb dropping simulation?” It seems that the Jewish community can barely do anything without some anti-Zionist taking issue. The event went on as planned, albeit with additional security and emotional distress placed on the student planning committee that was unprecedented. If anti-Zionism is not bigotry against Jews, what exactly does targeting a social for Jewish students have to do with Gaza? As most people are able to agree about bigotry, Antisemitism does not need to be physical violence to produce real harm. Universities are supposed to protect political free speech, but antisemitism stops being protected political expression when Jewish students are targeted, threatened, harassed, and blamed for the actions of the state of Israel. This line matters because free speech should encourage debate and protest, not cross the line into normalizing intimidation or hatred toward an entire group of people. Whether it’s protesting against former hostages, justifying or celebrating violence, or online harassment and intimidation, antisemitism continues to embed itself into the culture of college campuses. The AMCHA Initiative has a database of over 11,900 incidents of antisemitism on over 700 campuses. This issue is much larger than three California campuses; it exists across the nation in every place that Jews do. Despite this, it’s more important now than ever for Jewish students to remember Omer Shem Tov’s message: we need to bring in the light. We cannot afford to flinch as we face the abyss. Continue to host events, choose visibility over fear of bullying, and help build your community so that the next 1st year wearing a Magen David or an Israeli Flag Yamaka has a community to run to when chased across campus by “activists.” Jewish joy has become our strongest form of resilience and is itself an act of resistance. Jewish students belong on college campuses as much as anyone, and we aren’t going anywhere.
- Reza’s Story– Iran to Idaho
Reza was only 18 years old when he left Iran. He didn’t know any English, he had no extended family outside of Iran, and his future was teeming with uncertainty. All he carried with him was a belief that pursuing education might lead to a chance at a better life. At such a young age, Reza has had to persevere through political terror, religious turmoil, and cultural alienation. “We were facing a situation that I would have never imagined I would face in my entire life,” he explains, “and I was faced with this at age 19.” Today he is 23 years old, living part time with an Israeli family in the Bay Area and studying computer science at BYU Idaho, sharing his story with anyone who is willing to hear it. _________________________________________________ “Born and raised in Iran,” Reza came from a family that had been forged by adversity and resilience. At only 16 years old, his father’s life was turned on its head when both of his parents died in a car accident. Suddenly, Reza’s father had become responsible for raising his four younger siblings. Among them was a child only two-year-olds. Reza’s father never had a chance at an ordinary childhood. “He had to start working full-time to support the siblings, doing night school at the same time to get a diploma to be able to work in the daytime,” recalled Reza. Reza’s father married young, having met his mother around the age of 17. She played a crucial role in assisting him to raise his siblings, and they worked tirelessly to pave opportunities for their children. Reza is one of three siblings, having both an older and twin sister. In his home, the value of education was critical. “That's the way that you can always kind of have a better life, is just to have education, right?” Though education would prove central to Reza’s journey, the obstacle of religion was the first he had to overcome. _________________________________________________ Reza’s Religion Reza was raised Muslim. In post-revolution Iran, there is no other choice. Your cultural identity, community involvement, and national standing were all inextricable from religion. “There is no other option in Iran, since the Islamic Revolution in 1978. So, whoever is born and raised in Iran, they have to practice Islam and be part of it as well.” Reza describes how lucky he felt that his family were not fundamentalist, and family values always came before religion. At around age 16, his worldview began to change as he was exposed to social media for the first time, leading him to begin questioning the corruption he saw. This provided him with a perspective that was until then, unavailable to him. “I had first-time access to social media, including Instagram and YouTube, so I could actually see the world outside of Iran. At that time we have open access to all these platforms, but since I left the country in 2021, they've changed some rules that have filtered all this social media.” Reza began to question the Islamic faith together with the politics of his country. “And I think that was the time that I started questioning about Islam, and just, like, questioning everything about the faith. And, after doing a lot of research, I totally lost my faith to the Islamic belief, and I don't exactly remember the details of the timing, like, how long it took me to kind of, like, lose the faith. But I kind of lost the faith and the hope at some point too, like believing in God. So I kind of became, like, atheist at around age 16. But of course, I was never open about it, telling anybody, since there is no religious freedom back in Iran. But, like, this was my religious story until the age 18.” _________________________________________________ Reza Leaves Iran Reza was 17 years old when he first began researching ways to leave Iran, pursuing work and opportunities to study abroad. He had known some people who had done the same, and believed that this path was right for him. He began researching high schools in Eastern Europe, as he believed they had the right balance between a good education system and affordability. But as no one from his family has ever left Iran to study abroad in this manner before, convincing his parents was not easy. “I had an issue because my parents were not satisfied and happy with it, and they didn't want me to do that since I was like, 17 when I thought about doing this. And so they were a little bit concerned about all that, and not sure if it's good. But I kept going, and I still tried to research, and I talked to a lot of different people to be able to convince my parents that studying abroad is a good thing, that it's not a bad thing, necessarily. And it was a little bit of a hard decision for my parents because before I immigrated, there's been nobody who has gone… Everybody's just stayed back home, close to family, So, what I was doing was, like, a very new thing to their eyes.” After ultimately convincing them, Reza was accepted into a school in Slovakia. However, there was a 9-month delay for his visa due to the COVID situation in 2021, and he would not leave until August of that year. He left with a friend that was also going there for school without knowing any English; any language other than Farsi. “Without knowing any English or any other language than Farsi, I had to go just study in the senior year of high school. So it was pretty challenging, and I just didn't know the language, I didn't know a bunch of different things, I didn't know how to cook food on my own, I didn't know how to use the laundry, I just didn't know how. I was pretty much from scratch, and I was only 18 that time.” Reza emphasized the difficulty of living in a new country, not knowing the language and being unable to communicate. “I had to learn a lot of things on my own, specifically the language. It was pretty difficult to kind of learn from scratch, because people were constantly communicating with me, but I could not respond, because I didn't have that ability to understand what they were exactly telling me. And so I had to study both English and Slovak, because I ended up getting a job. I worked in McDonald's, and then I worked in a clothes shop, so I had to learn Slovak to also have an ability to serve as a customer service in those job positions as well. So I had to learn all those languages, and it was pretty challenging, but I'm happy that it worked out.” Reza had to be resourceful, working wherever he could while simultaneously learning both English and Slovak. The pressure was intense, and the feelings of isolation were growing. He had finally made it as a high school student in Slovakia. There, he was fortunate enough to have made a friend whose father worked in the U.S. Embassy. After being accepted to a Christian University in Nashville, Tennessee, he began attending church meetings with this friend. The more he attended these Church meetings, the greater his interest in the faith grew. After about 5 or 6 months, he no longer considered himself Atheist. “Everything was going pretty smooth. I was in a new faith, I was having a new hope in life. Things are different than I was expecting, you know? I was optimistic at that moment, and I was able to get the U.S. visa and go to Nashville for college.” When Reza had finally found himself in the United States, things had escalated back home. After the death of Mahsa Amini in 2022, protests for women’s rights spread like wildfire across the nation. Thanks to a 6 month delay on his visa, he elected not to visit home at the time. This decision would prove critical, as Reza would later find out that conversion from Islam to any other religion in Iran is considered Apostasy, and can be punishable by death. “I was only 19 when I found out about this. So I was pretty, like, I feel like I got hit by a bomb.” After deliberating with church leadership, he realized how serious of a danger going back home was. He discovered the U.S. had humanitarian programs of asylum that are designed to help people who would otherwise face serious persecutions back home. He found a lawyer based in Idaho that would help him. BYU Idaho happened to be affiliated with his church, and seeing as his lawyer was based in this state as well, Reza ultimately decided to begin the process of transferring schools. _________________________________________________ Reza Goes to California After staying for a while with a friend and studying at BYU Idaho, Reza began making plans for a trip to California scheduled for January 2024. “Everybody talks about the California Dreaming, right? Which is a new world, and everything is different in California. So I traveled to California in January of 2024 for the first time, and I went down in Los Angeles and I was pretty happy seeing, like, the beautiful palm trees and Santa Monica, all the beautiful beaches and everything. Pretty exciting, and I found some friends, met some people, I actually even accidentally found the synagogue as well. And I went there to see what it was like. I think it was Sinai Temple, probably one of the biggest synagogues that I know in SoCal. So I went there, and that's when things were a little bit more, uh, I guess a little bit more sensitive, because it was right after October 7. And so there were guards with the, like, guns, machine guns, and everything, so I was a little bit scared, like, okay, is this a military place? Maybe I shouldn't go.” And after visiting Wiltshire Boulevard, Reza described his fascination at meeting so many people from Iran. For the first time since leaving home, he found himself among a great number of people speaking Farsi once again. “I started talking to some, and I found that they were Persian Jews. That they immigrated to the United States after the Islamic Revolution, because they wouldn't have the safety anymore of staying in Iran. Since religious freedom didn't exist anymore after the revolution.” Reza found a sense of warmth and familiarity with these Persian Jews, something he never would have dreamed of since leaving his family in Iran. In time, his life experiences sparked a decision to change majors from Political Science to Computer Science, and he decided a trip to the Bay Area would prove illuminating. “And I was just sleeping in the car at that time, because I mean, I didn't have any place to stay, and Silicon Valley is not a cheap place to live, so I was sleeping in my car, and I had, like, a box of canned foods I brought all the way from Idaho. And, uh, was basically just traveling and just sleeping in my car, and seeing different places” It was at this time that Reza would make an Israeli friend who would invite him to stay with his family. “I felt like because I'm from Iran, Israelis are gonna be, like, you know, have a very distinct kind of, like, a perspective towards me, because I'm from Iran, and because of political issues. Which was not the case. I was actually a lot more, uh, I guess, welcomed because of the fact that I was from Iran, which was very surprising for me at that time.” “And I remember he was wearing the t-shirt of ‘Bring Them Back Home’ for, I guess it was for the hostages, if I'm not mistaken. And they offered me and my friend to stay with them without knowing us, which is an absolutely crazy move, like having somebody from Iran. That's probably, like, the biggest risk someone can take in their life. And, um, and we just stayed there, and we were there for, like, probably a week or two. And we just made a great relationship that time, and it was an amazing time.” After returning to school, Reza would continue to visit and stay with this family in the Bay Area. One of their children even attended BYU with him, becoming his roommate. Reza considers them his second family, and suffice it to say, has finally found a true second home outside Iran. _________________________________________________ At the Intersection of Cultures and Religions Reza has been a Muslim, an atheist, a Christian, an Iranian, an immigrant, and a student. The question of identity will always be one that is core to his journey. He has experienced the plights of propaganda living in an extremist theocracy, and has emerged from it with values that are truly inspirational. “I think each religion can have some good things and have some bad things. I think what is the most important thing is to keep the open-mindedness, and question things, and not blindly believe in anything just because you're being told.” In 2026, Reza continues to maintain a close bond with his family. His twin sister has since also left Iran, now studying dentistry in China. Reza continues to build a new life in the United States, studying computer science and telling his story while preaching his hard-earned truth of open-mindedness and the pursuit of freedom. Reza’s story has truly inspired me personally, and at only 23 years old, I believe he has lived a lot more life than most people out there. “We have the same goals. And we all want to go in the same direction. We want the freedom for ourselves, and we want to live in peace, in freedom, and be happy.”
- Graduation
My college experience has been full of numbers. I’ve been at UCSB for 4 years, which means 12 quarters. I’ve taken/slept through countless 8 AMs, received every grade value between 0 and 100%, watched the outside temp remain between 70° and 80° year-round, and calculated why it's financially irresponsible for me to get another 6 pack (the rack of 24 is just better value). Despite all these numbers, it's looking as though I’ll be grabbing my diploma alongside my buddies in 2 weeks time. So to put a gloss on 4 years of fun, learning, and hooliganism, here are some 5-7-5s, some bye-kus, if you will. ~~ 101 Santa Barbara, Goleta, Isla Vista, Los Angeles… home. Time 2021, Now it’s 2026, And I’m still a kid Friday Night Protein, Starch, Veggies. Laughter, Square tables and chairs. Shabbat at Hillel Water I oft ask myself: Do I drink enough water? The answer is no. The Beach I live on the beach; Don’t know when I will again… But I’ll be ready. The Beach Pt. 2 I have a roommate And we live in a garage; I live on the beach. Roommates I’m grateful for the Two roommates I’ve had this year. I hope I’ve been nice. Friends I met some friends first, I met others after that. All at the right time. Best Friends My best friends are cool; They make movies and music… And great role models Next I don’t know what’s next, If I’m eager or nervous, But it’ll be good Shema Shema Yisrael, Adonai Eloheinu Adonai Echad
- Poetry and Past
Erosion Drip Drip Drip Drip Drip One two three four five I was formed like clay Every relationship a drop of water Drip Drip Drip Drip Carving deep grooves Drip Drip Drip Every conversation a trail of sediment Drip Drip I look back on the valleys and curves And I see who formed them I look back on the past five years Drip And I see the canyon I’ve become The End? Why is it Why is it that must now know be fully formed What is it to grapple with the ties Between childhood and adulthood I am in a limbo Just weeks before I am to be expelled into the world To be sure of who I am When I am just starting Forming I am just beginning to Feel comfortable in these warm bones I am just learning what it is to make mistakes And to protect the child inside To say it is alright to be scared It is alright to not know For the sun is setting on my journey And the sun is rising on a new day Who Am I? Recently I’ve been wrestling with the concept of identity Who am I, what do I identify as, is there a place for me? (tw: war and violence) A little history: The furthest my family can be traced back to is Poland. I have no ties there but as far as my grandmother knows, that’s where we lived before Romania. Now in modern day Ukraine, my recorded family lived in a shtetl in Chernivtsi before World War II. I learned about the Holocaust at a very young age, as long as I have memories I have known. Two hundred, take in that number, two hundred members of my extended family were murdered in the Holocaust. I’d grown up hearing stories about family members shot and killed in front of their other family members, one story in particular about a family member taking off her earrings and begging the murderer to deliver them to her family and inform them about what happened before she was shot and thrown in a river. Some of my family escaped. Most of whom I am intimately familiar with managed to snag visas to Bolivia. My great maternal grandparents took a boat to that country where they didn’t know the language, and decided to take a risk and move away from the only home they’d ever known. They were forced to leave their parents and siblings behind in Romania in 1938, their family who refused to leave their home and believed that the rise of Hitler would not affect them. My grandmother, who is my best friend, was born in La Paz Bolivia and raised in Cochabamba. She grew up among the Aztec, Incan, and Quechuan cultures of South America and ate sopa de maní (peanut soup) and salteñas (basically South American dumpling) for lunch and dinner. Beatriz Dombrower moved to America when she was 18 with what she claimed to be not more than 50 cents in her pocket. She worked in factories to get by, and met her husband in America. She needed to get pregnant to avoid her husband Mario from getting drafted into the Vietnam war. My mom was born in the San Fernando Valley and I was born in Camarillo California. My mom and I have had the immense privilege of only ever knowing life in the U.S. I grew up living at my grandma’s on weekends, and eating sopa de maní and salteñas for lunch and dinner. I grew up with Spanish as my first and a half language, speaking it mainly when I was with my grandma. I have tried not to lose Spanish, and the culture my grandmother grew up and struggled in. I have tried to reclaim the Romanian culture my great grandparents grew up with and escaped from. I associate with the American culture I was cultivated and harvested in but none of these have fit just right.I struggled with my sexuality for years, flip flopping between whether the crushes I had on girls were in fact real and not a facet of heterosexuality. I learned that the internalized homophobia I was born and raised into prevented me from learning who I was and accepting myself fully. I’ve erased myself for years, I’m learning to rebuild myself. Not quite European, not quite Latina, not quite straight, simply an American fusion of all the cultures that came before me and the discoveries I’ve made along the way. The beauty of life, I have learned, isn’t that we are meant to be one way or the other, but that we simply exist out of an act of resistance. We are meant to keep the memories alive of those who came before us, of those whose voices are lost to history, and look ahead to those who we will stand in the footsteps of tomorrow.
- Passover Stories from the Jewish Gauchos!
As April comes to a close, the Jewish Gauchos are reflecting on many a Passover memory of this month, and Pesachs of years past. And as for the future, L’chaim to next year in Jerusalem! We asked and you answered! Here are the results of our passover preferences poll… Matzah Brei should be.... Do you eat matzah outside of Pesach? How long is your seder before the meal comes out? I prefer to finish my seder off with a few rounds of rage cage Pesach is one of the more accessible Jewish holidays for introducing non-Jews to our tradition. They get to join us in the seder, where we explain every drop of wine we consume and tell the story that will take them on the path of most guilt as they dip parsley in the symbolic tears of our ancestors. Yes, a little crazy for an intro to Judaism, but accessible nonetheless! For the first time during college, I was able to go home for a seder with my family and friends. This year, as my brother and I’s friends now fall into the adult category, the Breier siblings have begun a new tradition of leaving wine glasses at the table, trading them for red solo cups on the patio, and finding our afikomen in liquid form. My parents have long been maintaining the tradition of welcoming our non-Jewish friends to our seders, perhaps because we could all use a tiny break from the big family gathering chaos. But it’s also because our friends have enjoyed learning about our traditions through seder participation so much that they ask to come again each year. Since graduating college and being farther from many of his close friends, my brother has had to get creative and intentional with his social time and welcoming friends to our house to hang out (or pregame). It only takes a few red solo cups, that my mom then washes for him to reuse, to transform our backyard table and bring a taste of college to home. With a family friend about to graduate college, and her younger brother about to go off to college, we banded together after the seder to give young Elliot a little college orientation. His big sis even took down a bitch cup for him. The child too young to ask has now gained wisdom to spread to the socially dead of UCSD in the fall. My family’s deep value for sharing our home and our traditions has carried on throughout my life, and I carry it with me here at UCSB, inviting all friends to join me in my celebrations of community at Chabad and Hillel. Creating new traditions may A Pandemic Passover, contributed by Nadiv Meltzer In 2020, the world shut down right before Pesach. Amongst heart breaking losses such as not getting my driver’s license and missing the dissection unit in Chemistry, it also meant that my family could not get together for the first night Seder, a tradition I have looked forward to every single year I can remember. Now, I’m “lucky” enough to be from a big family, so my grandma, parents, three sisters, and I all gathered around the table. Because my father is a Rabbi, he utilized Zoom and streamed the seder to our entire congregation. The local newspaper decided to run a story about it, which meant we had a socially-distanced photographer stand in our side yard and take a picture of us, sitting around the Seder table, with the laptop Zoom-ing to the whole congregation. I wore basketball shorts with my button-up shirt, as was the Zoom fashion. Nowadays, although Pesach is one of my absolute favorite holidays because the whole family gets together in person, our 2020 Zoom Seder is a fond memory and perhaps even a microcosm of the perseverance and resilience of spirit that is so embodied by the story of the Israelite’s Exodus from Egypt. Maya’s Matzah Meals Pesach is always a time to get creative, from the classics like matzah pizza, to more elaborate and honestly unnecessary innovations like Matzah sushi. When you’re camping on Pesach, it might take putting yourself back into the sandals of the Israelites walking through the desert to piece together some meals with your matzah. Fig and Vine editor and resident adventurer Maya Kaye is no stranger to getting scrappy and making do with what you’ve got in the name of an excursion. When her camping trip with the excursion club overlapped with Pesach, she knew that at least no bears or fellow campers would be fighting for her stash of matzah. First on the menu for the excursion was chili, vegetarian for Maya. Cornbread or biscuits were replaced with the delightful dip of cardboard! I mean, matzah. Maya’s dipper was the talk of the group, getting those excursioners to adventure with their food. Up next was sandwiches to fuel the day of hiking. The fuel came in the form of turkey and bread, but no Kosher meat meant that cheese and lettuce had to take the spotlight in Maya’s sandwich. Matzah is not great for many things, but it makes a great mess of crumbs. Nothing like a dry pile of matzah, lettuce, and cheese to make you appreciate the outdoors. Maya’s cheese, lettuce, and matzah sandwich… well, sand.
- Artichoke Anatomy
The Heart I grew up savoring vegetables because of Ema. As a vegetarian, she insisted that her veggie dishes never sit politely as a side, but eloquently speak for themselves. Beet salad with an arugula base, eggplant topped with honey and goat cheese, and zucchini layered lasagna were all household delicacies. However, there was nothing I loved more than my mother’s artichoke. Perhaps what made it special was its simple preparation: a single glide of the knife to remove the vegetable’s thorny crown, followed by a 45 minute boil. She would then make two dipping sauces, one being the juice of a freshly squeezed lemon, the other a blend of seeded dijon mustard and mayo. Artichoke would appear on the table for every little occasion, such as straight A’s, birthdays, and Shabbat dinners. With an artichoke placed upon it, my plate became a swirling volute, generating and propelling my life. My parents were born and raised in Rockland County, New York. They were high school sweethearts, on and off through college. Eventually the couple moved to Israel, where my father served as a paratrooper and my mother worked for the Jerusalem Post. After six years (and a wedding facing the Jerusalem skyline), circumstances drew my parents back to the US, one of which being my father’s desire to receive a master’s degree in viticulture and enology. He began studying at Fresno State in 2002, and in May 2005, had his first and only daughter. Meanwhile, my mother worked as a graphic designer, though she enjoyed tangible mediums as well. Just as I completed kindergarten, we upgraded from our dreary rental and purchased a sunny, yellow home. Ema was immediately putting paintbrush to canvas, conjuring abstractions of her favorite places to hang perpendicularly to our new front door. Both my parents loved to keep their hands busy. When Aba wasn’t at the winery or on his desktop, he was in the kitchen. My father absorbed his culinary skillset from undergraduate courses in hospitality. He never shied away from an extra sprinkle of paprika or splash of olive oil to enhance flavor. He also insisted that time is an essential ingredient of every dish. Whenever Aba made challah, the dough would sit out for hours to rise both before and after being shaped. I love challah as an intersection of food and art. I was taught how to braid challah before I knew how to braid my own hair. The under-over motions ebb through me, and so does the spiral pull-apart of an artichoke. I do not remember the first time my parents and I sat around our kitchen table, each undertaking the globe, rapidly contributing to the pile of discarded bracts. Artichoke is a vegetable that takes effort. It requires the labor of both hands and the lower jaw to even graze at its quiddity. A special intimacy exists in conversation interwoven with unfastening, scraping, and relinquishing every layer of artichoke, until all impedimenta is placed in the center of the table, and a soft heart is pulsing on each plate. The Stem A facet of my childhood was accompanying Aba on vineyard visits across California. I became thoroughly familiar with the highways leaving the Central Valley, and with the varieties of crops grown beside the road. Aba would quiz me constantly. Are these pistachios or almonds? Clementines or lemons? Lettuce or kale? On our way to a plot in Salinas, we passed endless fields dabbed with purple and brushstroked with green. “Look Maya, these are where your artichokes come from.” However, Central Coast farm to Central Valley table only sits at the end of the story. Artichokes originate from western Mediterranean and North African domains. They were incipiently enjoyed for their spiny leaves, rather than the bud of the immature flower that we cherish today. In ancient Rome, the archaic artichoke was an adoration of the noble and wealthy. Artichokes lost popularity after the fall of the Roman empire, but continued to be cultivated by Arabs, who eventually brought them to Spain. Artichokes reappeared in Italy during the Renaissance period, having now developed its modern, spherical flower head. It wasn’t long until the thistle gained traction in France as well. Around the same time, Spanish settlers began introducing artichokes to the California coast, as the mild, foggy climate allowed for the cultivation of a taste of home. However, the California artichoke only became a thriving industry decades after the arrival of Italian immigrants in the late 1800s. By 1910, artichokes were shipped to Italian communities on the East Coast, and by 1920, the town of Castroville was supplying the United States with two thirds of its artichokes. Today, California grows nearly 100% of the artichokes that appear in supermarkets across the nation. The Outer Bracts On drives home, I would slump in the backseat while my father played Hebrew CDs. He sang along with ease while I choked on velar fricatives. Fresno has a Jewish population of 0.4%, so a large portion of my Jewish and Israeli identity felt insulated in our home. However, my parents did a phenomenal job of nurturing Jewish joy, rather than buckling into our otherness. We had Shabbat dinner each Friday night, and we committed ourselves to the spirit of every holiday. Judaism just so happens to demand food-centric tradition, although my parents have added their own flair. Apple turnip soup on Rosh HaShanah, roasted root vegetables on Passover, and homemade cheesecake on Shavuot represents Jewish prosperity through a story of flavors. From slavery in Egypt to the Holocaust, a pride in our peoplehood has always existed, despite all odds. Judaism is a dichotomy of the most vanquishing sorrows and uproarious jubilations. We take this in stride. To summarize the lion’s share of Jewish holidays, there’s a saying that goes, “they tried to kill us, we survived, let’s eat!” “We need to eat to survive,” voiced Roman Jews. In 1555, Pope Paulus IV issued Cum Nimis Absurdum, walling Jews into a seven acre (0.01 square mile) ghetto. Over 300 years, the ghetto’s population rose to 8,000 as Jews continued to lose more of their rights, such as the attainability of many ingredients in their living quarters. However, Sephardic Jews exiled from the Iberian Peninsula had just reintroduced artichokes to Italy. Non-Jewish Italians were intimidated by the prickly thistle, and therefore artichokes were allocated for the Jews. They had to be creative in how they prepared these vegetables, minding kashrut while making the most of their limited ingredients. Taking inspiration from Roman fried food, Carciofi alla Giudia (which translates to Jewish-style artichokes) became a staple in the ghetto. Carciofi alla Giudia requires few components as a double-deep-fried artichoke, sometimes garnished with lemon and salt. The dish immediately became a sensation across all of Rome. The ghetto was liberated in 1888 and today, Carciofi alla Giudia is a representation of Jewish tenacity at a dire time. The Inner Bracts Half a century later, Jews across Europe were faced with the horrors of the Holocaust. A multitude of miracles allowed for all of my great grandparents to enter the United States by the 1930s. My dad’s side came from Germany and Poland, and my mom’s side from Russia, Czechoslovakia, and Romania. Their beginnings in the US weren't easy, and my parents were the first generation to not grow up at poverty’s whim. Despite the hardships of relocating and entering new livelihoods, my great grandparents valued the continuation of our Jewish tradition. A way they brought this to forethought was through their diet. I come from a lineage of kosher kitchens, though with various levels of rigidity. In the sun-flooded kitchen where I grew up, my family only ate certified kosher meats, never mixed meat and dairy, and had separate dishes for meat and dairy meals. Since moving out, I’ve made a home in other kitchens, but have opted to observe kashrut just the same. I choose to keep kosher for its nod to my identity, its religious implications, and its guidelines to consume healthily and ethically. The Leaves Although my parents observed kashrut, their childhood menus looked much different than mine. Aba recalls a plentitude of carbs paired with soggy, overcooked vegetables – typical American home cuisine during the 70s-80s. His parents didn’t invest in a microwave until later, so his meals were prepared in the oven or on the stovetop. He grew up with broccoli, carrots, potatoes, celery, green peppers, and robust American cucumbers. He reports never seeing an avocado, eggplant, or mushroom at home, never mind an artichoke. In young adulthood, Aba worked in restaurants and participated in the Food and Beverage program at Rockland Community College. “I started bringing home these ‘strange’ vegetables to my parents house. They started to use them but it was problematic because my parents had an aversion to onions and garlic and all these vegetables are complemented by them. My parents, being very Ashkenazi, cooked everything in either corn oil or margarine, and there were very few herbs and spices,” he humorously recounts. Ema delineates a similar familiarity of produce in her childhood kitchen. She describes steamed frozen vegetables, string beans, and potatoes. She emphasizes the waxiness of the American cucumber, as well as her nostalgia for spitting out black watermelon seeds. Ema also mentions her parents’ love for making traditional Ashkenazi dishes. Matzah ball soup and cinnamon egg-noodle kugel were childhood staples, but she especially enjoyed my Pop-Pop’s matzah brie during Passover. At age 13, my mother made the choice to be vegetarian. For protein, she leaned on beans, especially chickpeas. “It starts with chickpeas and ends in bliss,” she proclaims. The Choke My parents broke out culinarily when they lived together in Jerusalem. They frequented Shuk Machane Yehuda, Jerusalem’s renowned outdoor market, purchasing uncharted produce and spices to experiment with at home. Persimmons, figs, and avocados added fresh new flavors, while cumin and za’atar enhanced the dishes they already loved. My parents shared their first artichoke at a friend’s apartment in 1997. They took more interest in the fibrous thistle after noticing the vibrant purple blooms of wild varieties among the countryside during a shmita year (Sabbatical year in which the land lies fallow). The Bible notes that when Adam and Eve were exiled from the Garden of Eden, God vowed to make the real world much more toilsome than their verdant paradise. Instead of fertile soil, Adam and Eve found themselves tending rocky, unyielding ground. According to Genesis 2:18, God told Adam that the ground would only spout kotz v’dardar (thorns and thistles), making food not impossible, but effortful to grow. It is only fitting that Jewish tradition recalls this tough flora as artichokes, a plant that has remained persistent since the creation of woman and man. The Talmud describes an abundance of artichokes throughout the Land of Israel in ancient times. They grew wild in the Galilee, but a cultivated alteration called kinras were commonly gathered as a food source. Today, the native wild species are still found across the country, as well as Globe and Violetto artichokes as modern cultivated varieties. It is mentioned in the Talmud that several rabbinic sages enjoyed kinras at their dinner tables. However, the labor that went into the harvest and preparation of the vegetable is emphasized. Artichokes are a complex gyre representing Jewish tradition and history. While the thistle challenges those who harvest, cook, and consume its contents, it has provided the Jewish people with nourishment for centuries. As the Romans forced Jews out of Israel upon destroying the Second Temple in 70 CE, then later the Bar Kokhba Revolt by 135 CE, the artichoke became a symbol of resilience in the diaspora. Tough outer bracts conceal the sharp pain of struggle and loss. However, the protective choke is thin compared to the heart – pride, tradition, song, peoplehood, and togetherness. The artichoke originated in the Mediterranean, and eventually spread westward to California. It paralleled the path of my ancestral and generational lineage. Finally, my parents returned to Israel, relishing in the sweet and nutty notes of the native vegetable, embracing the flavor of home, and later, infusing it into my Golden State upbringing. Bless you Adonai, ruler of the universe, who creates the fruits of the ground. ברוך אתה אדוני אלוהינו מלך העולם בורא פרי האדמה. Cynarine My tiny fingers dance around the artichoke. I’ve always worn my heart on my sleeve, but I am face-to-face with a vegetable that protects it at all costs. I take a swig of water, and it is sweet. Little do I know about cynarine, a compound that exists within the premature blossom that inhibits the sweet flavor receptors on my tongue. Whatever next greets the backside of my teeth reawakens my taste buds, as if steeped in sucrose or coated in honey. This is the secret of the artichoke; it shares its magic with everything else. Sunlight streaming into our yellow kitchen illuminates cherished memories of learning to cook and bake. Since then, I have exchanged recipes, including the simple boiled artichoke, with all the people I’ve come to love. How wonderful it was to grow up nestled between the artichoke leaves, deriving sweetness from every word exchanged over steamy bites. How miraculous it was to grow up nestled between the artichoke leaves, sanctioned to live softly, to divulge every fiber of my heart.
- Young, Gifted, and Israeli
The Portland Trail Blazers lost; they’re out of the NBA Playoffs. This hasn’t come as a surprise. The seventh-seeded Blazers were eliminated after scraping one win off of the San Antonio Spurs, the team currently boasting the second-highest odds at winning the championship. Any other year and casual NBA fans from around the country would collectively shrug as another wanna-be-underdog-story ends anticlimatically. But this year, many flooded to social media sites like X in a crude celebration not for the victory of the young and talented Spurs, but for the demise of the “zionist apologist,” “war criminal,” “IDF terrorist” Deni Avdija (all tweets from the last 24 hours). Politics were never Deni’s intention. He served part of his mandatory service in the IDF before his “exceptional athlete” exemption let him leave early. “I obviously stand for my country,” said the Blazer forward in a January interview with the Basketball Network. But still, even for that interview, Deni continues to get online hate simply because he is Israeli. This is an all-too-common story for Israelis in American culture. So as a small todah to all of these brave representatives who have faced xenophobia in the wake of their successes, I’ve compiled a list of some of the most prominent young Israelis today, from athletes to movie stars. Deni Avdija We had to start the list with Deni, who just this year became the first ever Israeli all-star in the NBA. In the last month, Deni had the second-highest scoring playoff debut game of all time with 41 points, brought the Trail Blazers to their first playoff appearance in five years, and finished third in the voting for Most Improved Player. He has been representing his country strongly, having won gold in back-to-back U20 European championships in 2018 and 2019. The 25-year-old had by far the best season of his career, despite all the hate. Ben Saraf / Danny Wolf These two Israeli rookies combine with Deni as the only three Israeli players in the NBA. At three, they set the record for the most Israelis ever in the league. Both these pros play in Brooklyn, which has seen an alarming uptick in anti-semitic events. Yet to truly feature in the Nets’ squad, Saraf and Wolf will appreciate the two more seasons before Israel challenges for a medal at the 2028 Summer Olympics in Los Angeles. Anastasia Gorbenko Gobrenko is a 22-year-old swimmer from Haifa. Already, she has won 8 World and European gold medals while breaking most of the Israeli national records for women’s swimming. After winning silver in the 2024 World Aquatics Championships in Qatar, Gorbenko was booed while on the podium. “I’m proud to represent my country,” said Gorbenko after the ceremony. An Israeli of Ukrainian heritage, Gorbenko has had to stay remarkably strong to exist in this world, let alone to break swimming records. Odeya Rush The 28-year-old Israeli actress is quickly becoming a household name. With major roles in The Giver, Goosebumps, and Lady Bird in the mid-2010s, Rush is now a star-level actress. She has the lead role in the new comedy-horror Corporate Retreat which has already debuted at the Brussels International Fantastic Film Festival and is coming out on May 22nd in the U.S. Rush lived in Haifa until her family moved to Alabama when she was nine. She is unapologetic about her support for Israel, often helping bridge the gap between America’s sensationalized media and real events happening in Israel. Max Oleartchik Max is the oldest person on this list. He is a 39-year-old bassist from a musical family. His father, Alon Oleartchik, has been a Polish-Israeli rock singer since the 1970s. Alon’s father, Max Olearczyk, was a Polish composer in the 1940s and 1950s. Grandson Max was part of the four-piece indie-rock band Big Thief from 2016-2024. As a founding member of the band, he was a massive part of their first five albums. Their most recent album, Double Infinity, which he was not involved in the creation of, features lines that seem to reference him and his absence. The song Los Angeles in particular, with lines like “two years feels like forever,” seems to be about Max. Today, Oleartchik is an active advocate for peace in the Middle East. He shows how to openly show frustration with the Israeli government while still remaining a proud Israeli individual.
- Where We Meet by Yaeli Dukler
This risograph zine is a reflection on my grandparents, their home in Israel, and the memories held within it. I was born in Israel and moved to the United States with my family when I was six years old. Immigrating here, we left behind our family, friends, language, and sense of place. As months turned into years, California eventually became my home. Although I've spent the majority of my life in the U.S., my Israeli identity is just as important, as my family has maintained our culture, language, and values within our home. Whenever I return to Israel, I stay with my grandparents in their apartment, a space that holds years of personal and collective memory. Their home is deeply tied to my sense of family and belonging. The building itself is old, and they are now, after more than 50 years, mandated to move out permanently so it can be renovated. They must say goodbye to the place they have long called home. This past year, my family has experienced significant loss and grief. Alongside the loss of loved ones, the displacement from this home has further deepened that sense of rupture. This book is an attempt to hold onto what remains, to reflect on memory, family, and the complicated process of loss.
- Not Perfect, Still Ours
Beth, a young Ashkenazi-German Jewish woman who was raised in Berlin in the early 2000s. She went to college in California, where she met her now wife, Abaynesh. She loves to travel and spend all her time outdoors. Abaynesh: A Beta-Israel Jewish woman who was raised in Tel Aviv in the early 2000s before her family moved to California. She loves art and culture, bringing a new life to everything that she touches. Spotify- Not Perfect, Still Ours Let’s set the scene! Beth and Abaynesh just got home from their honeymoon abroad! They’ve planned a special Shabbat with both of their families at their newly established home in rural California. The gravel crunched louder than Beth expected. She stood in the doorway of their small rural California house, dish towel in hand, watching the first car pull up in a cloud of pale dust. The late afternoon light stretched everything long and golden—the fence posts, the oak trees, the thin line of smoke already curling from the kitchen window. “They’re early,” she said, half to herself. “They’re always early,” Abaynesh replied from behind her, not looking up from the cutting board. “Your mother believes in preparedness as a spiritual value.” Beth turned, managing a tight smile. “It is a spiritual value.” Abaynesh grinned. “So is arriving with ten people at once and no warning.” As if on cue, a second car appeared behind the first. Beth groaned softly. “Oh no.” The door barely had time to open before voices filled the house. “Bethy!” Her mother stepped in first, arms already outstretched, carrying a covered dish balanced precariously in one hand. Behind her came her father, quieter, scanning the space with soft curiosity. “Oh, it’s beautiful,” her mother said immediately, already moving past Beth into the kitchen. “Smaller than I imagined, but charming.” “It’s exactly what we wanted,” Beth said, closing the door against the breeze. Before she could say anything else, the second car doors slammed in quick succession, and laughter—loud, overlapping, musical—carried up the path. Abaynesh didn’t wait. She slipped past Beth and flung the door open just as her family approached. “Enat!” she called, pulling her mother into a hug that seemed to fold time in on itself. Greetings overlapped—Hebrew, Amharic, English blending into something fluid and warm. Someone kissed cheeks, someone clasped hands, someone pressed a container into Beth’s arms before she could even register who had given it to her. For a moment, everyone crowded in the doorway. Then there was a pause—subtle, but real. Beth’s mother and Abaynesh’s mother both stepped toward the kitchen at the same time. They stopped. “Oh—please,” Beth’s mother said, gesturing. “No, no,” Abaynesh’s mother replied, smiling just as politely. Beth felt it like a held breath. Abaynesh broke it easily. “Or,” she said, slipping between them and taking both dishes, “we all go in and make a mess together.” The kitchen filled quickly. Beth tried to keep track of everything—what was going in the oven, what needed chopping, who needed space—but the rhythm she was used to kept slipping out of reach. Her mother measured carefully, narrating as she went. “If the oven runs even a little hot, it will burn the bottom—” Abaynesh’s aunt, beside her, added a handful of spice to a simmering pot without measuring at all. “It will be fine,” she said, tasting and adjusting again. “What is that?” Beth asked, hovering. “Just something small,” Abaynesh said, not looking up. “Taste.” Beth did. It was rich, unfamiliar, layered in a way she couldn’t immediately name. “It’s not what I expected,” she admitted. Abaynesh smiled. “That’s the point.” Beth laughed, but her eyes flicked to the oven. She forgot the challah. Not completely—just long enough. It was the smell that caught her, sharp and unmistakable. “Oh—no, no, no—” She rushed to the oven, pulling the loaf out too quickly, setting it down with a dull thud. The bottom was dark—too dark. Her chest tightened. “I ruined it.” “It’s not ruined,” Abaynesh said, glancing over. “It’s burnt.” “Only a little.” “It was supposed to be—” Beth stopped herself. Perfect, she almost said. Like home. Abaynesh took a knife, sliced off the worst of the bottom, and broke off a piece. She tasted it, chewed thoughtfully, then shrugged. “Still bread,” she said. “Still Shabbat.” Beth let out a breath she hadn’t realized she was holding. As the sun dipped lower, the house shifted. Voices softened. Movements slowed. The table, mismatched and slightly too small, was filled with dishes that didn’t quite belong together and yet somehow did. When it was time, Beth reached instinctively for the matches. Abaynesh’s hand hovered near hers. They paused. Beth glanced up. There it was—the quiet question neither of them had fully asked yet. Whose way? Which words? Which rhythm? “Together?” Abaynesh said. Beth nodded. They lit the candles side by side. The blessing came out slightly uneven—Beth starting a fraction earlier, Abaynesh’s cadence different, their voices overlapping and then finding each other again. It wasn’t polished. It wasn’t practiced. It was theirs. The candle tipped just after. A small, sudden shift—the table leg catching unevenly on the floor, or someone brushing past too quickly. The flame wavered, then leaned, wax spilling onto the table. “Wait—” “Careful—” Hands moved all at once, voices rising, chairs scraping. Then it was upright again. The flame steadied. Silence hung for half a second longer than necessary— —and then someone laughed. Soft at first, then louder. Another joined in. Soon, the whole table was laughing, the tension dissolving into something easier, lighter. Beth found herself laughing too, breathless. Dinner unfolded in layers. Dishes passed back and forth—some familiar, some entirely new. The flavors didn’t match in any traditional sense, but no one seemed to mind. Stories surfaced. Beth’s father spoke about Berlin winters, small Shabbat tables, and the careful preservation of tradition. Abaynesh’s mother spoke about Tel Aviv, about movement, about the older stories carried from Ethiopia. At first, people listened politely. Then they leaned in. Questions came—curious, not cautious. Laughter threaded through the heavier moments. Connections formed in unexpected places. Beth looked around the table and felt something shift—this wasn’t just a gathering. It was a weaving. She slipped into the kitchen without announcing it. The quiet hit her all at once. The hum of conversation dulled behind the wall, replaced by the soft clink of dishes and the faint crackle of candlelight. She leaned against the counter. “It’s a lot,” Abaynesh said from the doorway. Beth turned. “I wanted it to be perfect.” Abaynesh tilted her head. “Why?” “Because it’s our first one. Because both our families are here. Because—” Beth gestured vaguely toward the other room. “This matters.” Abaynesh stepped closer. “It is perfect.” Beth shook her head, half-laughing. “The challah is burnt. The candles almost fell over. I don’t even know if we did the blessing right.” Abaynesh reached past her, breaking off another piece of challah. She handed it to Beth. “Eat.” Beth did. “It tastes fine,” she admitted. “Exactly.” Beth looked at her. “You’re very relaxed about all of this.” “I’m not relaxed,” Abaynesh said. “I just don’t think perfect is the goal.” “Then what is?” Abaynesh smiled, glancing back toward the other room. “This.” It started with a voice—low, steady. A song Beth half-recognized. Someone else joined in, then another. The melody shifted slightly as it grew, different harmonies folding over each other. Hebrew words anchored it, but the tune moved—stretching, adapting. Abaynesh took Beth’s hand and pulled her back into the room. They stood at the edge at first, listening. Then Beth joined—tentative, then stronger. Abaynesh’s voice came in beside hers, different but fitting. It shouldn’t have worked, all those variations layered together. But it did. It filled the room. Later, the table broke into smaller circles. Parents compared stories. Siblings joked. Someone asked Beth what it had been like growing up Jewish in Berlin. Someone else asked Abaynesh about traditions Beth had never even heard of. The questions weren’t careful anymore. They were open. Beth sat back, watching it all. By the time the last car pulled away, the house was quiet again. The table was a mess—wax hardened in uneven pools, dishes stacked precariously, crumbs scattered everywhere. The challah, what remained of it, sat slightly lopsided on the counter. Beth looked at it and sighed. “I’m sorry.” Abaynesh raised an eyebrow. “For what?” “For… all of it not being—” She stopped herself. Abaynesh crossed the room, broke off the last piece of challah, and handed half to Beth. They stood there in the dim light, eating. “It didn’t go how I planned,” Beth said. “No,” Abaynesh agreed. Beth looked around—the mess, the remnants, the quiet after something full. “Everything that mattered still happened,” she said slowly. Abaynesh smiled. “Yes.” Beth leaned against her, the weight of the evening settling into something warm and steady. In the stillness of their home—the one they had just begun to build—nothing felt mismatched anymore.
- Proof of Life - Photography from Spring Break
I’ve always loved photography and the act of capturing bits and pieces of our busy lives. Taking a moment to pause is something that I think is so crucial and beautiful. That being said, here's a few moments I captured during spring break! Late night drag show - On the way to the drag show in North Hollywood, I noticed this eclectic window display for Saint Patricks day that I absolutely loved. It's a little disquieting but every piece fits uniformly in its place. Sunsets in my backyard - sunsets like these in my backyard in Thousand Oaks make me step out of my house and take a second to enjoy this beautiful moment with my family. Flowers in my front yard - The roses are in bloom this time of year. When I’m typically leaving my house in a hurry, noticing the roses makes me pause and appreciate the beauty only a few feet from my front door. Beach date - My boyfriend and I’s favorite beach in Malibu is so picturesque. We traditionally go there for sunset and bring a picnic with us. I feel so lucky to live in California where this beach is only 40 minutes from where I live at home. Goose! - The excitement of this moment is pretty self explanatory but the Disneyland geese and ducks are always a highlight of my trips to Anaheim. Fireworks over Matterhorn - Another picture from that same trip to Disneyland over spring break. I caught the tail end of the fireworks show from Tomorrowland, where the fireworks rise out over the Matterhorn in a breathtaking display. Back home - Returning to IV after spring break ended. I feel so lucky to be part of the incredible Jewish community we have here, one that makes me feel like when I am returning, I’m returning home.
- February Love
Dearest Readers of Fig and Vine, You’ve made it through another February. It was a tough one, each year filled with more Instagram Valentine launches than the last. Did you find yourself thinking, when will it be my turn? When will I get to be the gross couple on some sad single soul’s Instagram feed? I’m here to help! Here is a Sonnet of love and deep desire, sure to lift you out of your lonely lull. Simply fill in the blanks, and to me you’ll be sharing your thanks. Sonnet 155 Oh _____ , the matzo ball of my eye! Down Camino Pescadero we go, As I confess_____, awaiting thy reply. Under Chabad lights, I stare at your punim aglow. Thou could be the Fig to my Vine, And we shall harvest a love full of _____. A love so fruitful we could boast it online, We’d decorate our feed with _____. Sure, we’re no Maya and Allen, Their roadtrip filled love measured by the gallon. But at least I’m no ginger, And you’re more than O-Kaye. Cupid points me straight to your _____. Boy am I glad that we matched on _____!
- Peace as a Litmus Test for Zionism
As a result of ongoing conflict surrounding Israel, the concept of “Zionism” is constantly being defined and redefined to fit different agendas. Although peaceful realization has long been an important aspiration, as it is for any project of national self-determination , Zionism does not demand blind faith in peace with those who violently deny Jewish indigenous rights, nor an unconditional commitment to political arrangements detached from conditions on the grounds. Unfortunately, this idea was muddled in a recent articl e in the JTA by Shanie Reichman. She argues that Zionism entails a political resolution with Palestine as a necessary condition of the belief itself. She frames older generations of Jews, who have understandably become skeptical that peace is attainable as having “abandoned Zionism.” This argument is flawed for so many reasons. It’s worth saying explicitly that wanting peace is entirely consistent with Zionism, since the movement is fundamentally about Jews living freely and securely in Israel, and peaceful relations are often the most effective way to achieve that end. But Zionism has never demanded pacifism, nor does it obligate Jews or Israelis to pursue peace at any cost, regardless of violence, ideology, or repeated rejection by the other side. Reichman bases her argument on the observation that support for Israel has declined sharply among younger generations of American Jews. While she claims that 69% say it’s important to stand up for Palestinians and 67% say it’s important to support Israel, the embedded link to these statistics is dead and could not be independently verified. Even if we assume that such data is correct, her analysis is questionable. “Standing up for Palestinians” can mean a variety of different things and does not necessarily mean opposing Israel’s existence or Zionism. For many Jews, standing up for Palestinians could mean pushing back against Hamas , or supporting humanitarian aid, or expressing moral issues with how easily civilians are affected by war. The author is using these statistics as if they are undeniable proof of this abandonment of Zionism, when this isn’t the case at all. Skepticism about achievable peace between Israelis and Palestinians does not negate Zionism; it only reflects an apt assessment of the current political reality. As a reminder, this reality has been shaped by decades of rejected peace deals , violence, and failed negotiations. No one is saying Israel is perfect, but putting most of the blame on them is ahistorical and unhelpful. How can Reichman expect Israelis to live side-by-side with people who want nothing else other than to kill them? This is the core issue. Her entire article implies that the growing lack of Jewish faith in peace is the main problem, not the ideology driving Palestinian nationalist antizionism. She's confused the chicken for the egg. Israel is constantly being held to a standard of perfect optimism or nonviolence, which creates an unrealistic and unfair expectation that is not applied to other national movements. No other countries are expected to continuously seek peace, let alone send aid to a Terror organization which exists to kill them. One line toward the end of the article encapsulates this misguided logic fairly well: “ giving up on the possibility of a political resolution is not pragmatism; it is surrender. ” This claim completely conflates acknowledging a political reality with completely abandoning values or a Zionist identity. A political resolution between Israel and Palestinians would require so much compromise on both sides, a compromise that Hamas and the PA have shown time and time again it is unwilling to make. If Israelis were to accept these claims as a reality, this would essentially handcuff them to peace process strategies that we know from experience don't work . Instead of making Zionism conditional on how the rest of the world treats Jews, we could support Jewish self-determination regardless. When skepticism about the prospect of peace or concerns for Israeli security is conflated with an abandonment of Zionism itself, we lose the ability to distinguish specific policy critiques from the type of dehumanization that antizionist bigotry promotes. In the world that offers Jews little margin for error, this is simply tacking on one more way in which we are judged. Ultimately, debates over the popularity of Zionism are a distraction. Mo ving past these arguments about Israel’s right to exist would allow far more energy to be directed toward the difficult work of building a future grounded in security, dignity, and peaceful coexistence.











